Whose reading is it anyway? Why children's choices matter in reading

Published on November 17, 2026

Why children’s choices matter in reading—and how adults can give them more say in what, how and why they read.

By Jo Beer

There is considerable care and effort behind encouraging children to read. Teachers make time for stories, librarians find books for particular readers, and parents read favourites aloud long after they could recite them from memory. Yet alongside this care, it is worth asking how much room children have to shape their own reading lives. Are the texts available those adults hope children will read, or do they also reflect what children actually want to read?

Teresa Cremin makes an important distinction between reading for pleasure and finding pleasure in reading. A child may enjoy a story chosen by an adult, while reading for pleasure involves the child’s own desire to read and some ownership of the experience. Choice is therefore essential to reading for pleasure. Sharing wonderful books can introduce possibilities, but children also need opportunities to follow their interests and make decisions of their own.

Make room for their favourites

Children’s reading interests do not always fit neatly with adult preferences. A child might want the next book in a familiar series, a comic featuring a television character or a digital guide to a favourite game. Another might choose a graphic novel, listen to an audiobook or return repeatedly to the same collection of football facts. These choices can reveal what the child gets from reading: familiarity, humour, information, companionship or a connection with something enjoyed elsewhere. Before suggesting different books, it is worth finding out what makes the current choices appealing. A series, for example, offers characters and settings the reader already knows, with pleasure in anticipating the next adventure. A book linked to a television programme, film or video game brings familiarity too, and opportunities to share an interest with other readers.

Offering choice means making these texts available and giving them attention. What is displayed and recommended shows children which reading choices are valued. If comics are tucked away while novels take centre stage, children may reasonably conclude that some preferences count for more than others.

Get to know the reader

The National Literacy Trust’s research into children’s reading highlights the importance of choice, access, encouragement and freedom from pressure. An invitation to choose is most useful when there is something available that the child wants and can access. Finding that particular something requires knowledge of children as readers alongside knowledge of texts. A conversation might begin with what a child watches, plays, makes or wonders about. “What have you been interested in recently?” offers a starting point for children who would struggle to name a favourite author. For a child fascinated by insects, a librarian or teacher might gather a photographic guide, a comic and a digital article. Browsing together can reveal whether the attraction lies in collecting facts, studying pictures or following a story.

Children can help shape collections too. A suggestions notebook or a conversation about missing titles can reveal interests adults have overlooked. Acting on these suggestions is important: seeing a requested text arrive demonstrates that children’s preferences influence what is available.

Offer possibilities, then listen

Although it is important that children have agency in choosing the texts, they cannot choose a format or author they have never encountered. Adults have an important role in widening reading experiences and the range from which they can choose. Short read-alouds, library visits, audiobook samples and time to browse can provide tantalising introductions to something new without requiring an immediate commitment.

Any recommendation, though, should leave the decision with the reader. “You enjoyed the humour in that comic; I wondered what you would think of this” explains the suggestion while allowing the child to welcome or decline it.

Giving children choice also means accepting that they may decide not to read a particular book, or not to finish one they have started. Perhaps the subject interested them, but the effort of reading felt overwhelming. Perhaps the child expected a story and found mostly information. “What were you hoping it would be like?” can help an adult understand whether reading together, trying an audio version or choosing another text might be welcome.

Let children own their responses

Children’s agency extends beyond selecting a text to deciding what they think about it and whether they want to share that response. Aidan Chambers’ Tell Me approach welcomes likes, dislikes, puzzles and connections as starting points for conversation. Children can disagree with an enthusiastic recommendation or remain unconvinced by an ending. Mary Beard’s recent Booker Prize remarks remind adults that reading can challenge and unsettle, while Katherine Rundell calls for “reading for power” alongside pleasure. Children need room to express responses beyond enjoyment.

There should also be space to read without producing a review or completing a comprehension task. Having that choice is part of owning the experience.

A reading life of their own

Children need adults who know them, know texts and can introduce possibilities they might otherwise miss. That knowledge should widen children’s choices and help them make decisions with growing confidence.

For reading to become something children choose for themselves, their preferences need to shape what is available and how reading time is spent. This includes choosing familiar favourites, declining recommendations and leaving some books unfinished. Choice and agency are essential to a reading life that children can call their own.

References

About Jo Beer

Jo Beer is an education consultant with over 30 years’ experience as a primary teacher, school leader and university lecturer. She brings a love of children’s literature, storytelling and reading aloud to her work, helping teachers use books to inspire imagination, reflection and meaningful conversation.